Jeff Merrill | Sioux Falls Realtor

By Jeff Merrill | August 27, 2026

You found a house you can afford in Sioux Falls, but the mortgage won’t come together. Maybe your credit’s still healing, maybe you’re two years into self-employment with income a lender won’t count yet, maybe a past bankruptcy is still on the clock. Then the seller says the words you didn’t expect: “I’ll finance it myself.”

That’s a contract for deed. It goes by other names too — land contract, installment sale, seller financing on the deed. In this market, with the median Sioux Falls home around $335,000 and 30-year rates sitting near 6.7 to 6.8 percent, more buyers are asking about it, and more sellers of paid-off homes are offering it. It’s legal in South Dakota, it’s real, and it can be the right move. It can also cost you everything you put in if you sign the wrong version of it.

Here’s how it actually works, and what I tell every buyer who asks me about it.

The seller keeps the title. You keep everything else.

In a normal sale, you get a mortgage, the bank pays the seller, and the deed transfers to you at closing. A contract for deed skips the bank entirely.

You and the seller agree on a price, a down payment, an interest rate, and a monthly payment. You move in and take over the property — taxes, insurance, repairs, the leaky water heater, all of it. But the seller holds legal title the whole time. You don’t get the deed until you’ve paid the contract in full, either by making every payment or, more often, by refinancing into a real mortgage down the road.

A few things that trip buyers up:

• You’re the owner in every way that costs money, and not the owner on paper. You pay the Minnehaha or Lincoln County property taxes and carry the homeowners insurance, but your name isn’t on the deed yet.
• The interest rate is usually higher than a bank rate. Sellers financing their own property often ask 8 to 10 percent, sometimes more, because they’re taking the risk a bank wouldn’t.
• Balloon payments are common. Many contracts run a low monthly payment for three to five years, then a large balloon comes due — the assumption being you’ll refinance or sell before then. If you can’t, that’s a problem.
• The down payment is negotiable but often bigger than you’d expect. Ten percent or more is typical, because the down payment is the seller’s cushion.

Why South Dakota buyers use it — and where it bites

The appeal is obvious. No underwriting, no lender overlays, a faster close, and a path to owning when the bank keeps saying no. For a buyer rebuilding credit or a self-employed contractor who’ll qualify in eighteen months, a contract for deed can be a bridge.

The risk lives in one word: forfeiture.

If you default on a contract for deed in South Dakota, the seller can move to cancel the contract, take the property back, and keep the payments you’ve made — and that process can move faster than a traditional mortgage foreclosure. Under a standard mortgage, you build equity and get the protection of a full foreclosure timeline. Under a poorly written contract for deed, you can lose the house and your money if you fall far enough behind.

Now, the news isn’t all bad, and this is the part most out-of-town blog posts get wrong. South Dakota courts don’t rubber-stamp forfeitures. A forfeiture clause is only enforced if the amount the seller keeps bears a reasonable relationship to the actual damages. If you’ve paid down a big chunk and made real improvements, and the seller would walk away with a windfall, a South Dakota court can refuse to enforce the forfeiture and can order restitution — the court has equitable power to adjust the outcome under South Dakota’s foreclosure statutes (SDCL 21-50-2). In plain terms: the more you’ve paid in and the more you’ve put into the house, the more the law leans your way. But you do not want to be the person testing that in court. You want a contract that protects you before anything goes wrong.

There’s a federal layer too. The Consumer Financial Protection Bureau treats contracts for deed as an extension of credit. If the seller meets the definition of a creditor, they’re subject to the Truth in Lending Act and Regulation Z, which means real disclosures — the rate, the finance charge, the payment schedule — not a handshake and a number scribbled on a napkin. A seller who won’t put those terms in writing is a seller to walk away from.

How to do it without getting burned

If you’re going to buy on a contract for deed in Sioux Falls, treat it with the same seriousness as a mortgage — because it is one, just without the bank’s guardrails. Here’s the checklist I’d insist on:

1. Record the contract with the county Register of Deeds. An unrecorded contract for deed is an invitation for problems. Recording puts the world on notice that you have a claim to the property. Do it right after signing.
2. Run a title search and buy an owner’s title policy. You need to know the seller actually owns the home free and clear before you pay them a dime. A South Dakota title company — not an escrow agent, because we close through title companies here — can run the search and issue a policy.
3. Confirm the seller has no mortgage in default. If the seller still owes a bank and that loan has a due-on-sale clause, your contract could trigger it, and the seller’s lender could foreclose out from under you. Verify the payoff situation in writing.
4. Get every term in writing with a full amortization schedule. Price, rate, monthly payment, balloon date, who pays taxes and insurance, what counts as default, and how long you have to cure a missed payment. Vague contracts favor the seller.
5. Have a South Dakota real estate attorney review it before you sign. This is the single cheapest insurance you’ll ever buy on a deal this size. A few hundred dollars up front beats losing your down payment later.
6. Have a realistic exit. Most contracts for deed are meant to be temporary. Know exactly what you’ll need to refinance into a conventional or FHA loan before the balloon hits — the credit score, the seasoning, the income documentation.

And before you go the contract-for-deed route at all, make sure it’s really your only option. A lot of buyers assume they can’t get a mortgage when they actually can. It’s worth running the numbers on how much house you can afford in Sioux Falls, getting a real pre-approval versus a pre-qualification, and checking whether down payment assistance through SDHDA closes the gap. Owning the deed from day one, with a bank’s protections behind you, is almost always the stronger position.

Frequently Asked Questions

Is a contract for deed legal in South Dakota?

Yes. Contracts for deed are legal and used across South Dakota for residential, agricultural, and commercial property. They’re recorded with the county Register of Deeds, and if the seller acts as a creditor, they’re subject to federal Truth in Lending disclosures. The key is a properly written, recorded contract — not an informal agreement.

Who holds the title in a contract for deed?

The seller keeps legal title until you pay the contract in full. You get possession and take on the costs of ownership — property taxes, insurance, and maintenance — but the deed doesn’t transfer to your name until the final payment or a refinance pays the seller off.

What happens if you miss a payment on a contract for deed in Sioux Falls?

The seller can start a forfeiture to cancel the contract, retake the home, and keep the payments you’ve made, and it can move faster than a bank foreclosure. That said, South Dakota courts can refuse to enforce a forfeiture that would hand the seller a windfall — the more you’ve paid in and improved the home, the more the law protects you. Your contract should spell out how long you have to cure a missed payment.

Can you buy a house with bad credit using a contract for deed?

That’s the main reason people use one. There’s no bank underwriting, so a seller can approve you when a lender won’t. But expect a higher interest rate, often 8 to 10 percent, and a larger down payment, because the seller is taking on the risk the bank declined.

Is a contract for deed a good idea?

It can be a smart bridge if you’ll qualify for a normal mortgage within a few years and the contract is written to protect you. It’s a bad idea if the terms are vague, the contract isn’t recorded, or you have no realistic plan to refinance before a balloon payment comes due. Have an attorney review it first.

The bottom line

A contract for deed can put you in a Sioux Falls home when a bank won’t, but you’re trading the protections of a mortgage for speed and flexibility — and the fine print decides whether that trade works out. Record it, insure the title, get an attorney’s eyes on it, and know your exit before you sign.

If you’re weighing a contract for deed against a traditional mortgage, or a seller has offered you one and you’re not sure it’s fair, I’m happy to walk through the terms with you and help you figure out the strongest path. Reach out anytime at 605-201-2846 or siouxfallsgreathomes.wordpress.com.

---

About Jeff Merrill
Jeff Merrill leads The Jeff Merrill Team, powered by eXp Realty, serving Sioux Falls and the surrounding South Dakota communities of Madison, Mitchell, Canistota, and beyond. He helps motivated buyers, sellers, and new agents cut through the hype in real estate with honest guidance, hands-on mentorship, and a track record of real results. Connect with Jeff at siouxfallsgreathomes.wordpress.com or 605-201-2846.

This article is general information, not legal or financial advice. A contract for deed is a binding legal document — consult a licensed South Dakota real estate attorney and your tax professional before signing.